First - I must ask myself: Oh why, oh why, did I go to the movie this morning?
You know how people always say that the book is better than the movie? Well - in this case this is really more than true. I do not understand how anyone could take such a great story - with such fantastic potential and completely screw it up!
I think that the script must have been really very short. I do not believe that any of the characters had any lines that were more than 3 or 4 words long. There was absolutely no character development. Even Wendy found herself laughing when Dr. Carlisle Cullen (played by Peter Facinelli) walked into the ER - you know - the scene where Bella (Kristen Stewart) is taken to the ER after Edward (Robert Pattinson) saves her from nearly being smooshed by a van in the high school parking lot... It was truly laughable - Dr. Cullen walks into the ER - while putting on gloves (oh - quick side note here - I am a REAL LIFE ER doc and I don't walk into a patients room ever while snapping my gloves into place - seemed very forced to me). Anyway - back to my rant - Dr. Cullen's face is more than vampire-pale, ghastly - it is like clown makeup white.
As far as the acting goes - well, I think that Peter Facinelli did a great job playing Dr. Cullen (aside from the make up and the glove-snapping). I am saddened by the fact that Jasper (Jackson Rathbone) was portrayed as a slightly mentally retarded Edward Scissorhands type and that Alice (Ashley Greene) and Rosalie (Nikki Reed) were not just a little bit cuter. I can't complain that much about the Alice and Rosalie characters as they did not get that much face time - but I really did expect that these two (actually that the entire Cullen family) would be breathtakingly beautiful and I really was waiting for some super model type beauties to show up in these roles.
Edward was of course very good looking - very hot and he did a great job looking the part. But, I feel like he was not given enough material to really work with. His character could have been really great but again, really limited character development. I was really bummed that they did not give Robert Pattinson a better script - a better movie to act in. So Robert - you are not blamed for this one - I think you looked awesome and did what you could. I will picture your face as Edward while I finish these last two books of the Twilight Saga.
Elizabeth Reaser (she played Esme - Dr. Carslile Cullen's wife) did a great job. Also - not much camera time but she looked great and her character seemed different than the crazy little chick she played on Grey's last season. Nice job, Elizabeth.
OK - that's all I've got today as a movie critic. I think I'll go back to doing what I do better - making funky onesies and cute little dresses and of course - being a real life ER doctor. Maybe I will try that glove-snapping trick as I walk into my patients rooms tonight. Hmmm....
No comments:
Post a Comment